These deliciously soft baked pumpkin chocolate chip cookies are loaded with chocolate chips, spices and bursts of cinnamon. This is the only pumpkin cookie recipe you will need!
I know. Pumpkin cookies are always cakey. Are these cookies going to be cakey?
Well, yes and no. I definitely wouldn’t call this a recipe for crispy pumpkin chocolate chip cookies. We are dealing with pumpkin! It’s never going to be crispy. There is just too much moisture. It’s very possible that you may classify them as cakey but they are not as cakey as some other pumpkin cookie recipes.
I also found that the longer they sit, the less cakier they seem. Sure, right out of the oven, they kind of remind me of muffin tops but a few hours later they just seemed like a soft cookie to me. I also tried to reheat them the next day in the oven (5 minutes at 350°F) and this seemed to re-crisp the outer edges a bit and make them more cookie like.
Now. Let me tell you why this soft baked pumpkin chocolate chip cookies recipe rocks.
All you need is a whisk…
For once the recipe instruction does not begin with “in an electric mixer…” All you need is your whisk and a few mixing bowls. You don’t want to cream the butter and sugar here because we are trying to avoid getting a cakey cookie. An electric mixer puts way too much air into the batter. Your whisk will gently do the job of blending and sifting your dry ingredients together.
This pumpkin cookie recipe uses the whole can!
The next best part about this recipe is that you don’t have any leftover pumpkin from a can. Seriously, how annoying is it when the recipe says to only use a few tablespoons or a cup?
Ok. Fine. I too am guilty of posting a recipe that uses only part of a can of pumpkin (ahem, mini bourbon pumpkin cheesecakes and butterscotch pumpkin cake bars recipes) but I am thrilled to present to you a recipe that uses the whole can! These truly are pumpkin cookies. That all being said, you do end up with 5 dozen cookies.
The recipe uses Cinnamon Sweet Bits…
I discovered this gem of an ingredient while looking through my King Arthur Flour catalog. I finally added it to my order one day and did not regret it! These little cinnamon bits are basically a combination of cinnamon and sugar. When you add it to a recipe, whether it be cookies, a pear upside down cake or my whole grain pumpkin spice pancakes, you end up with little bursts of melted cinnamon sugar. If you can’t get a hold of it, just add some extra cinnamon along with the rest of the spices. You can also use pumpkin pie spice in place of the individual spices.
You can add 1 ½ teaspoons of cinnamon with the rest of the spices instead of adding cinnamon sweet bits at the end. You MUST press the balls down twice with your fingers. These cookies do not spread much. This will give your cookies a flatter rounder shape.
Serving Size: 2 cookies
Amount Per Serving: Calories: 160 Total Fat: 8g Saturated Fat: 5g Trans Fat: 0g Unsaturated Fat: 3g Cholesterol: 22mg Sodium: 68mg Carbohydrates: 21g Fiber: 1g Sugar: 10g Protein: 2g
You can add 1 ½ teaspoons of cinnamon with the rest of the spices instead of adding cinnamon sweet bits at the end.
You MUST press the balls down twice with your fingers. These cookies do not spread much. This will give your cookies a flatter rounder shape.